
Overall rating
4.0
Alright, let's talk about 广州天诚鞋商行 over on 1688. This is a shoe-focused store, and honestly, with 32 products, it's a pretty tight lineup. If you're hunting for chunky, oversized sneakers, this might be your spot, but you need to read the fine print before you hit that buy button.
First, the good vibes. The seller is sitting at a perfect 5.0 rating, and dispatch to your proxy warehouse is fast—averaging just 1.4 days. That's the domestic shipping time from the seller to your local agent's warehouse, not the long international haul to your door. So, if you're used to waiting weeks for a seller to even pack your stuff, this is a breath of fresh air. It's pretty much a breeze on that front.
Now, the part that should make you pause. The recent review count is super low (only one unique piece of feedback, repeated twice), but it's a massive red flag. Someone wrote in Italian (so we know these are getting shipped abroad) and said: "Great quality for the price, but the only thing is they run very small. I wear a 45.5 in Air Force and these fit me small in a 47..." Read that again. A size 47 fits like a smaller size? That's not a minor sizing quirk; that's a serious inconsistency. If you wear a US 10.5/11, you might need to size up a lot, or maybe even go two sizes up. And on 1688, returns are a hassle, so being stuck with a shoe that's too tight is a real possibility.
There are no defect records flagged, which is nice, but the sizing issue is the elephant in the room. The store has basically zero social proof. With only 1 total review, you're taking a gamble on consistency across their 32 SKUs. The top saved products are just "Oversized Sneaker" repeated, so it seems like they specialize in one style. Good if you know your size, bad if you're guessing.
The Brutal Verdict: The speed and the perfect rating look good on paper, but with almost no buyer feedback and a clear warning about sizing, this is a "buy only if you're okay with a gamble" kind of store. If you have wide feet or like a snug fit, skip it. If you're okay with potentially playing the shoe lottery on sizing, the quality-to-price ratio gets a thumbs up from the one guy who actually bought them. Just make sure your agent has a good return policy—you might need it.